For years, teachers, parents, and policymakers have worried that something was going wrong in America’s classrooms. Now, the numbers leave little room for debate. The latest results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) — known as the Nation’s Report Card — reveal that U.S. students are struggling at levels unseen in decades. Reading and math scores for high school seniors have plummeted to historic lows, with nearly half of students unable to demonstrate even basic math proficiency and almost a third failing to reach minimal reading standards. The results paint a sobering picture: millions of young people stepping into adulthood with weaker academic skills than their parents and grandparents, and a society quietly gambling away its future competitiveness.

What’s most alarming is that this isn’t just a temporary blip caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. While school closures, remote learning, and social upheaval certainly accelerated the decline, evidence shows that scores had been stagnating or even falling for years before 2020. In other words, the pandemic didn’t start the fire — it merely fanned the flames of a long-burning crisis. Behind the test scores lies a complex mix of systemic underinvestment, cultural changes, technological distractions, and policy missteps. The scary truth is that American kids aren’t catching up, and if current trends continue, the gap between what young people know and what society demands will only widen.

A Decade of Decline

To understand how dire the situation has become, we need to step back and look at the broader trajectory. Achievement in reading and math actually rose steadily through the 1990s and early 2000s. Researchers celebrated progress that seemed to cut across racial and socioeconomic divides. But around 2012, things began to change. Test scores plateaued and then started to decline — slowly at first, then sharply. By 2024, the numbers left no room for optimism: 12th-grade reading scores fell to their lowest point since NAEP began tracking them in 1992, while math results sank to levels not seen since the mid-2000s.

This isn’t just one test telling a grim story. Independent assessments such as NWEA’s MAP Growth and Curriculum Associates’ i-Ready echo the same trend. International measures, like the Program for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies, reveal that even American adults are scoring lower in literacy and numeracy. As Peggy Carr of the National Center for Education Statistics put it, there’s a “dwindling middle” in terms of skills — more people clustering at the very top and the very bottom, with fewer in between. The achievement gap is widening, and that has long-term consequences.

What makes the decline especially troubling is its persistence across age groups. It’s not just high school seniors: eighth graders are showing their worst science scores in over a decade, while younger students are missing foundational skills in reading and math. Even preschoolers are struggling with focus and behavior issues that teachers trace back to disruptions during the pandemic. The erosion isn’t confined to one age bracket; it’s structural, stretching from kindergarten through adulthood. That suggests deeper problems than any single curriculum or test could explain.

The Pandemic Effect — and Its Limits

It’s tempting to pin all the blame on COVID-19. Remote learning upended classrooms for over a year in many districts, leaving millions of kids without consistent instruction. Teachers reported students unable to write full sentences, complete basic math tasks, or sustain attention for even a few minutes. The Center on Reinventing Public Education found that by 2023, the average student was still less than halfway to a full academic recovery. Pandemic-related trauma and mental health struggles only compounded the problem, creating classrooms filled with students who were disengaged, anxious, or far behind.

But the decline didn’t start in 2020. NAEP data shows that scores were stagnating in the 2010s, well before the virus disrupted schools. Matthew Soldner, acting commissioner at the National Center for Education Statistics, has emphasized that the “foundation was already crumbling.” COVID just knocked it over. In that sense, the pandemic was more of an accelerant than the root cause, exposing weaknesses in teacher support, curriculum design, and student resilience that had been brewing for years.

What’s more, the recovery has been painfully uneven. While some districts with strong funding and targeted interventions are helping students regain ground, many others lack resources. Chronic absenteeism has surged, with over a quarter of students missing enough school days to be flagged as at risk in 2022–23. For low-income students, English learners, and children with disabilities, the learning losses have been greater and the road back steeper. If schools fail to close these gaps soon, experts warn, the pandemic will leave a lasting mark on an entire generation.

The Technology Paradox

Technology plays a double-edged role in this story. On the one hand, smartphones and social media have changed how kids interact with information. Psychologist Jean Twenge notes that achievement scores started to decline around 2012, the very year when smartphones passed the 50% ownership threshold in the U.S. The timing is striking. Short-form content and endless scrolling have reshaped attention spans, rewarding quick novelty over deep concentration. Teachers say students today struggle to read long passages or follow multi-step math problems — skills that require the kind of focus increasingly rare in a world of constant digital distraction.

Yet technology can also be part of the solution. Adaptive learning platforms, personalized tutoring software, and data-driven interventions can help struggling students catch up. The problem arises when technology substitutes for genuine learning rather than supporting it. If AI tools are doing students’ homework for them instead of guiding them through problem-solving, they create dependency rather than mastery. Schools must thread the needle carefully: using technology as a scaffold without letting it become a crutch.

Still, the cultural shift cannot be ignored. Families read fewer books together, kids spend more time on screens, and even classroom syllabi have shifted toward excerpts and bite-sized texts rather than sustained reading. As a result, students build less “reading stamina” — the endurance needed to comprehend long-form arguments or dense nonfiction. This erosion of deep literacy has profound implications for civic life, where the ability to parse complex texts and weigh nuanced arguments is vital for democratic participation.

Policy Missteps and Funding Gaps

While cultural and technological factors play their part, education policy has often made things worse. Federal accountability policies that once pushed schools to focus on raising achievement began to weaken in the early 2010s, after the Obama administration issued waivers from the No Child Left Behind Act. Congress later replaced it with the Every Student Succeeds Act, which gave states more leeway but also less pressure to close gaps. Analysts argue this easing of accountability coincided with the achievement slowdown, particularly for low-performing students who benefited most from federal oversight.

At the same time, funding for critical education research and oversight has been cut. The Institute of Education Sciences, which tracks performance and funds interventions, has seen its resources reduced. Meanwhile, debates over curriculum — from phonics versus whole language in reading to conceptual versus procedural math — have left classrooms inconsistent and often ineffective. The so-called “reading wars” illustrate the problem: some children miss out on phonics instruction, while others never build comprehension skills. Both groups fall behind.

Even when money flows in, it doesn’t always go where it’s most needed. Pandemic relief funds helped some districts launch tutoring programs and summer academies, but many of those initiatives were temporary. Sustaining them requires long-term investment and political will. Without it, the inequities that widened during COVID will harden into lasting divides between students who had resources to recover and those who did not.

The Unequal Toll

Perhaps the most sobering aspect of the crisis is how unevenly it has fallen. The achievement gap between top- and bottom-performing students is wider now than at any point since NAEP began. Girls, who had closed many gaps with boys in math and science, have seen sharper declines in some areas, reversing years of progress. Students from low-income families, English learners, and children with disabilities face disproportionate setbacks. In early childhood programs, even 4- and 5-year-olds are showing troubling signs of developmental delay, sometimes expressed as extreme behavioral issues in classrooms.

These disparities matter not just for fairness but for the nation’s future. Employers already report shortages in math-intensive fields such as cybersecurity, AI, and semiconductors. If lower-performing students are systematically excluded from pathways into STEM, the U.S. risks not only deepening income inequality but also losing ground in global competitiveness. Programs like Northeastern’s Bridge to Calculus show what’s possible when students are given intensive, real-world instruction, but such opportunities remain rare. Scaling them up requires money, commitment, and a willingness to prioritize struggling learners.

Equity also has a cultural dimension. Communities with limited resources often have fewer libraries, after-school programs, or safe study spaces. When families face economic stress, children have less time and support for reading or homework. That means reversing educational decline isn’t just a school problem — it’s a societal one. Without broad efforts to close these gaps, the decline will reinforce cycles of poverty and exclusion.

Rebuilding a Culture of Learning

Solutions exist, but they require both urgency and patience. Early screening for reading and math difficulties can catch problems before they compound. Structured, explicit instruction — especially in phonics for reading and foundational concepts for math — has strong evidence behind it. Tutoring, summer programs, and after-school interventions can help students regain lost ground, especially when they are intensive and consistent. But these interventions cost money, and without sustained funding, they risk disappearing before they make a lasting impact.

Beyond policy fixes, there’s a deeper cultural task: restoring the value of learning itself. Reading widely, working through challenging math problems, and engaging with complex ideas aren’t just school tasks; they’re habits that shape lifelong curiosity and resilience. Families, schools, and communities all play a role in making these habits normal again. That might mean instituting daily reading routines, creating local math clubs, or celebrating academic achievement as publicly as we do athletic victories. Without a cultural recommitment to deep learning, even the best policies will fall short.

The good news is that societies can reverse declines when they choose to. History shows that educational crises can spark reform movements that leave systems stronger. But doing so requires honesty about the scale of the problem and the willingness to invest in solutions that work, rather than chasing easy fixes or ideological battles.

A Wake-Up Call, Not a Death Sentence

The latest test scores are a warning siren. They tell us that American students are falling behind not just compared to past generations, but compared to peers around the world. The causes are many — policy missteps, cultural changes, technological shifts, and the shock of a global pandemic. The consequences, if left unchecked, will be profound: weaker economic growth, greater inequality, and a civic culture starved of deep reading and critical thinking.

But decline isn’t destiny. The crisis is real, but it is not irreversible. By combining evidence-based instruction, targeted funding, teacher support, and community engagement, the U.S. can rebuild a stronger educational foundation. The choice is ours: panic and hand-wringing, or clear-eyed urgency and action. The scary truth is that kids have fallen behind. The hopeful truth is that we still have the power to help them catch up — if we treat education as the public good it has always needed to be.

Loading...